April 2, 2018

The Nursery Labor Shortage — Is H-2A the Solution?


By Steve Shropshire, Attorney

Oregon nurseries are facing pressing labor shortages. Many have turned to mechanization, but the industry still needs human hands. In recent years, those hands have not been available.

Many nurseries are considering the H-2A temporary agricultural worker visa program as a potential solution. H-2A is a federal guest worker program allowing agricultural businesses to hire foreign workers. This article provides an overview of the program and the associated challenges.

H-2A Overview

The H-2A program traces its origins to the 1953 Immigration and Nationality Act. The program allows U.S. agricultural employers to bring foreign nationals to the United States to fill seasonal and temporary agricultural jobs that the employers are not able to fill with U.S. workers. The duration of an H-2A visa is limited to one year, with the possibility of extending to a maximum of three years.

The program is administered through the U.S. Department of Labor and the Department of Homeland Security's U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). In addition, the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries and the Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Division participate in oversight of the program at the state level.

H-2A is very complex and full of potential traps for the unwary. This is true both of the application process and of program compliance once guest workers are hired.

H-2A Qualification Requirements

The H-2A program has several threshold requirements:

  • First, there must be a shortage of sufficient workers who are able, willing and qualified, and who are available at the time and place needed to perform the labor services.
  • Second, the needed labor must be agricultural in nature.  “Agricultural” labor or services includes activities such as planting, raising, cultivating, and harvesting of any agricultural or horticultural commodity.
  • Third, the work must be full-time—at least 35 hours per week.
  • Fourth, the need for the work must be seasonal or temporary in nature.
  • Finally, employment of foreign workers may not adversely affect the wages and working conditions of U.S. workers performing similar work.H-2A Process

Employers wishing to use H-2A must go through a rigorous application process. This process is time consuming and unpredictable. Under the best case scenario, employers need to start the process no fewer than sixty days before workers are needed.

First, employers must obtain state and federal certifications demonstrating that the work qualifies for the H-2A program and that U.S. workers are not available. Next, employers must file an I-129 petition with USCIS. If the petition is approved, foreign workers from eligible countries must apply for an H-2A visa.

Overview of Significant H-2A Requirements

The H-2A program imposes many compliance requirements on employers. Some of the most important are discussed here.

Wages. In Oregon the hourly rate paid to H-2A workers must be at least as high as the Adverse Effect Wage Rate (AEWR). For 2018, the U.S. Department of Labor set the AEWR in Oregon and in Washington at $14.12 per hour.

Housing. Employers must provide housing at no cost to H-2A workers and to domestic workers in corresponding employment who are not reasonably able to return to their residence within the same day.

Meals. Employers must either provide employees with three meals per day or furnish free and convenient cooking and kitchen facilities where workers can prepare their own meals.

Transportation. Employers must reimburse workers for reasonable transportation and subsistence costs incurred to travel to and from the work location from their country or place of origin. In addition, employers must provide free daily transportation between the workers’ living quarters and the employer’s worksite.

No discrimination against U.S. workers. Employers must treat domestic workers in corresponding employment positions no worse than the foreign workers. This includes the hiring process, wages, hours, transportation, and housing.

H-2A Challenges for Oregon Nurseries

Oregon agricultural businesses face a number of H-2A-related challenges. Housing availability is foremost. Oregon’s land use laws restrict residential construction on EFU-zoned property, making it difficult to provide on-site housing for H-2A workers. The high mandated base wage is also an issue. Oregon has the second highest AEWR wage rate in the nation, making it difficult to compete with out-of-state nurseries.

Compliance with H-2A implementation requirements is also a challenge. The program imposes many requirements related to recruiting, payroll, housing, and reporting. The federal penalties for non-compliance range from approximately $1,700 to $17,000 per violation.

Finally, it is important to understand that nurseries are considered co-employers under state and federal law when working with labor contractors. This means that a nursery is liable for full compliance with all aspects of the H-2A program by labor contractors.

Agricultural businesses have successfully used H-2A; but success under the program requires customized advice and training. Nurseries that adequately prepare may find the program to be a viable solution to their labor shortage problem.



Back to Top